Interpersonal Relationship
Courtesy of the official website : http://www.thetruthisntpretty.com/
For the detailed synopsis, please visit the link below.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ugly_Truth_(film)
Above is the synopsis for the movie The Ugly Truth, which was screened in Singapore theatres on 17th September. According to Knapp’s model of relational development, there are 10 stages in a relationship. Stages 1-5 are coming together and stages 6-10 are coming apart. The first time the two protagonists met is known as initiating. Stage 2: experimenting was when Mike helped Abby to win Colin’s heart. Mike got to know Abby really well after interacting with her during the coaching process. Stage 3 took place at a much later time in a pub. It was when Abby realised that Mike actually thinks the same way as her – the “we” thinking (relational identity). Stage 4: integrating was skipped and they proceeded onto Stage 5: bonding which was shown at the last scene in the movie.
However, for the case of Colin and Abby, they went through the Knapp’s model from stage 1 to 4, but they skipped stage 5 and proceeded on to stage 6 – differentiating. This is where Abby decided to be truthful about her feelings towards Colin and that sealed up the channels of communication between them. Stage 10: terminating occurred when the relationship ceased to exist and the parties moved on from the relationship and Abby managed to develop a new relationship with Mike.
Abby was attracted to the physical appearance of Colin and this general perception of physical attractiveness exerts a consistent positive impact on the relational formation. The judgement of physical attractiveness in this case was influenced by the societal norms. Some conditions Colin had that made him attractive, according to the cultural norms, was handsome, financially stable, successful career and muscular. These were some of the criteria which he possessed that attracted Abby. The impact of physical appearance diminished over the course of the relationship between them. Abby realised she does not really like Colin’s character and feels that he is too good for her and eventually, developed feelings for Mike instead.
We tend to form relationships with the people around us and this does not exclude Abby and Mike. They were colleagues in the television company and hence, there is a greater opportunity for them to interact. This reduces the uncertainties about one another. By falling in love with one another, they reciprocate their feelings and this minimises risks. The perception that someone likes another serves as a form of validation and in turn boosts his or her self esteem.
However, both of them did not realise their similarity in character in the beginning when they met. In fact, Abby detested Mike and felt disgusted by him. After interacting with him and self disclosure, the sharing of information about self that the other person is unlikely to know, Abby realised that her thinking is somewhat similar to Mike’s.
It takes two to maintain a relationship and according to the Equity Theory, individuals in relationships seek to maintain a balance of costs and rewards that are relatively equal to those of their partners. The balance maintains the long-term viability of the relationship. Therefore, the under-benefiting will suffer and the over-benefiting will rationalise. If you are giving more than what you are receiving or vice versa, then you should be concerned as there would be a higher risk of dissoution of this relationship.
Any views about interpersonal relationship? Feel free to post your comments and discuss about it!


20 Comments:
At October 4, 2009 at 11:32 PM ,
Shimin said...
I agree with your analysis. People tend to trust their 1st impression of a people and normally fall in love with them because of their physical appearance, like Abby's feelings towards Colin. In the movie, she mentioned about Colin hitting 9 out of 10 criteria of a checklist which she uses to determine how good a guy is. I think this is not what a relationship should be.
At October 4, 2009 at 11:36 PM ,
Dwayne said...
I believe it is exactly the society that drove people to set such conditions that an ideal partner must possess. However, Abby realized in the end that society's view does not represent how she feel about her partner and in the end she decided to follow her heart and chose Mike instead.
At October 4, 2009 at 11:43 PM ,
en said...
I agree with you that the society has a part to play in driving people to set such conditions. This could be due to how society perceive love as - not purely just a liking towards each other, but rather, more of the benefits that they can get out of this relationship. Hence, the definition of relationship has definitely evolved over time.
At October 5, 2009 at 8:37 PM ,
Xue Li said...
The Equity Theory does affect most decisions in a relationship, but it does not define how all relationships may work. For example, in a situation of spousal abuse, the victim may choose to keep quiet about the matter instead of seeking justice for himself/herself. It may be due to the conventional mentality that dirty laundry are not to be hung in public, and the foolish hope that it will only be a one-time event. Thus, instead of calling it quits, or dissolving the relationship, the victim may choose to continue under-benefitting and suffer.
At October 6, 2009 at 10:41 AM ,
KJ said...
From reading the post, I realise there are 10 stages to relationship development and that as the relationship progresses, a different stage of development is reached. This has however led me think about whether the stages of development can reverse or backtrack. Is it possible for a relationship in the fifth stage to recede back to the third or fourth stage? or is it that only way the relationship can go is up to the fifth stage?
At October 6, 2009 at 9:54 PM ,
en said...
This is a good question brought up. Yes indeed we can skip to certain stages and our relationship with our partner can actually go the reverse way. For instance, you could hate that person at first, but when you get to know him or her better, you feel that he or she is not exactly as bad as you think. Then you start to progress up stages 1-5. This means that I can start at stage 6 and move to stage 9 then back to stage 4. You do not have to follow it step wise.
At October 9, 2009 at 4:20 PM ,
augustine said...
The knapp's model of relational development is an interesting one as it gives a detailed analysis of interpersonal relationship. It also tells us one important factor - man and woman are usually attracted to the physical appearances of their other half and later, develop a liking for their internal beauty. Hence, things like love at first sight are a common amongst man and woman. For example, in abby's case, she fell in love with colin's physical appearance instead of his character. However, abby realized she does not really like colin as she discovered that she doesn't love him for who he is but only because of his appearance.
At October 9, 2009 at 5:16 PM ,
Anonymous said...
Normally,we will form a relationship with people who are in our social circle. This is the case for abby and mike. Whereas colin was abby's neighbour and there is a possibility that they will form a relationship since they live near each other. However,in my opinion,it is because mike gets to interact more with abby and gets to know her character more than colin does and vice versa,that's is why abby fell for mike in the end.
At October 18, 2009 at 10:37 PM ,
Xuanqin said...
I think Abby should choose Mr walking checklist as he is the perfect guy that most girls dream for. Like what you have mentioned, we tend to form relationships with people around us like in the case of Mike and Abby. However, Colin and Abby are actually neighbours, thus there is an possibility that they may form a relationship between them. Thus, i felt that Abby should have chosen Colin over Mike.
At October 18, 2009 at 11:11 PM ,
en said...
Even though Colin may seem to be the best choice, Abby is not who she really is when they got together. Thus, honesty does not have a place in their relationship. What Colin likes, is actually a facade that Abby put up. Towards the end, Abby could no longer pretend to be the woman that Colin likes. Hence, she chose Mike over Colin because she can express and communicate in her true self.
At October 28, 2009 at 9:49 PM ,
Aaron said...
As you have mentioned above, according to Knapp's model of relational development, there are 10 stages in a relationship and we can skip the stages. Abby realised that there was a better guy whom she could stop pretending to be the elegant woman when she was with him. Thus, at this point in time, the relationship of Abby and Colin could no longer proceed to Stage 5 but Stage 10, where they started breaking apart. Nevertheless, Abby and Mike have proceeded to Stage 5 of getting together where none of them have ever thought of it.Therefore from this movie, I learnt that even though there is a perfect guy right besides you, it doesn't mean that you will definitely choose him over other guys. This is because relationship is a process where truthfulness and understanding is important for maintaining it.
At October 29, 2009 at 11:01 PM ,
Anonymous said...
I wonder if abby actually liked colin when she was pretending to be who he likes. Initially i feel that she might go for him because of what you've mentioned - physical appearance. Our first impression is normally how we judge people whom we've just met. Thus, it is to a large extent that we will have a perceptual biasness towards someone and tend to jump into conclusion that he is the perfect man.
At October 30, 2009 at 12:12 AM ,
Joshua said...
"Abby was attracted to the physical appearance of Colin and this general perception of physical attractiveness exerts a consistent positive impact on the relational formation."
I would call this, love at first sight. In general, females always have this misconception, or you could call it generalization, that good-looking guys will have good characters. Well, it's just like calling someone a "handsome nice guy" or "pretty friendly girl". We do not usually say "ugly nice guy" or "fat friendly girl" right?
As such, I do not really believe in 'love at first sight', as it may bring about misconceptions of the other party. I believe the most important factor in maintaining a relationship is to have mutual understanding of each other, and not physical appearance. Fortunately, this point was shown in the movie 'The Ugly Truth', where Abby realized Mike was more suitable for her after constant socializing with each other.
At November 2, 2009 at 10:47 AM ,
P.L said...
In the beginning there was little contact between mike and abby. After abby and colin went out for a date and colin went home, mike and abby had their first intimate contact through haptics. This shows that there is an increase in the perception of liking for each other.
At November 3, 2009 at 12:28 AM ,
Anonymous said...
I do not agree with your point that if you are giving more than you should in a relationship, you should be concerned that there will be a higher risk of dissolution. this is because in any relationship, there is always a give and take by both parties involved. there can never be a balance achieved whereby there is an equal amount of sacrificing and receiving in a normal relationship.
At November 3, 2009 at 10:59 PM ,
en said...
It is true that it is not easy to measure the benefits and how much one should give or take from a relationship. However, it is relatively so that the risk of dissolution will be higher for a couple that is giving and taking pretty much the same as compared to one party contributing more to the relationship and the other just reaps the benefits without any contribution at all. This could lead to him or her questioning their relationship.
At November 8, 2009 at 10:58 PM ,
JJ said...
First impressions of our friends actually leaves a deep impression on us, especially of our other half. I think that this is because we tend to judge people and measure them with the yardstick that is the first impression we have of them. Even though it does not really matter in the end what our first impressions of our partner is, we would be captivated by their appearance and based on our first impressions of them, consider them as a suitable candidate as our other half.
At November 8, 2009 at 11:01 PM ,
Amy said...
From the start of the movie, I have already treated Abby and Colin's case as "blind dates". It is really impossible to pair those two up when they have little or what I say, "forced" contact. I believe that a good relationship will only occur when both are in constant contacts, not when one is trying real hard to find out about the other party.
At November 8, 2009 at 11:02 PM ,
Unknown said...
there is nothing that could define what is a good relationship. not everyone has one. every relationship is bound to face failures.
a failed relationship is only when both or one of the party did not bother to face the problems of their relationship and give up.
but no one has a perfect relationship in their entire life. so no one can really define what it's like when they have absolutely no experience of it.
At November 8, 2009 at 11:41 PM ,
Clarisse said...
Appearance does matter for a first date but I believe that the characteristics one possess will actually help us determine who is a better partner for life as it will be the person's habits and characteristics that we will be living with for the rest of our lives and not his or her outer appearance.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home