Communication

Sunday, October 25, 2009

Culture

According to Geert Hofstede, culture is the “collective programming of the mind which distinguishes the members of one group or category of people from another and it includes systems of values and values are among the building blocks of culture”.

As I was searching online, I chanced upon a few articles on recent events that sets me thinking. One of these articles was on the declining birth rate in China and people are debating if the government should abolish the 30 year old one-child policy.
Here is the link: http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2009-10/21/content_8822496.htm

In another article earlier, the government has made a very clear stand about not abolishing this policy as it has helped China to control its population and prevent a baby boom. This is what makes China a different society from that of the USA. It is a highly collectivist country where its people normally conform to government policies. Being a communist country, they believe in equality in reward distribution. And this culture is passed down the generations.

As compared to the USA where only specific aspects of a person’s life is influenced by ingroups, China is a society where the ingroups influences their lives tremendously. For example, their government decides what they want their citizens to think and see through censorship and filtering of news about its own country. They will omit negative reports and only publish news that praises their country. They even spend money to restrict access to certain websites that they deem unfit for their netizens. It has even gone to the exteme that the government had to intervene with the number of children each family can have. This is a result of agenda setting in mass communication.

On the other hand, United States of America is an individualistic society where freedom and social recognition is highly valued. In such a culture, social behaviour is determined largely by personal goals, attitudes and values of collectivities. Whereas Asian countries like China are collectivist society, where harmony and equlity in distribution is honoured.

However, be it a collectivist society or an individualistic one, there is bound to be ethnocentrism in most societies.  Ethnocentrism is a belief that one’s culture is superior to all others and tendency to judge all cultures by one’s own criteria. A few months ago, an outburst of racial riots in Xinjiang, China has caught the attention of the world. A deadly fight between Uighurs and Han Chinese in southern China broke out as Uighurs fear erosion of traditional culture and the persistent violence in the area between the two ethnic groups since 1991. Uighurs identified the information and images circulating on the Internet of the lynching, by a crowd of Han, of Uighur workers in a toy factory in Guangdong as a form of contempt and this led to the outbreak. Cases like this are a common sight in other places of the world. In America, Black discrimintion is evident in today’s society. In Latin America, Latinos are facing discrimination and increasing hate crimes committed against Latino immigrants. Below is the link to a video of one such incident of a Latino hate crime victim:
http://www.cnn.com/video/#/video/living/2009/10/21/lia.shendo.cnn

Cultures is something that determines who we are. To what extent do you feel that our lives are greatly influenced by culture? What are your views on a collectivist or individualistic society?

Below are links to the various articles that I’ve found:
These are on China’s one child policy and related articles

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2009-10/24/content_8843109.htm

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2009-03/26/content_7618314.htm

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2009-08/26/content_8620149.htm

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2009-07/24/content_8466365.htm

This one is on the Latino Americans:

http://www.commondreams.org/headline/2009/10/13-2

19 Comments:

  • At October 26, 2009 at 10:26 AM , Anonymous Sue said...

    I'm a solid product of collectivism. Whenever I have a different way of doing things, I tend to discard that thought and do what is considered as a social norm. I do not dare to be different and I would prefer to portray myself in a way which society defines as being appropriate. I'm being brought up in a way to think that harmony is very important, and I value filial piety. I think that makes me very much a collectivist.

     
  • At October 26, 2009 at 10:37 AM , Anonymous Clara said...

    I beg to differ. Even though I grow up in a collectivist society, I'm an individualist. I usually make decision based solely on my own goals. However, it is true that the idea of being different is not found in most of us. I'm concern that I might not be accepted by our society if my actions are different from what most of the people are doing. I'm also guilty of ethnocentrism. I have this tendency to feel that my culture is the best.

     
  • At November 4, 2009 at 10:54 PM , Anonymous ning said...

    though we may say that we make decisions or do things that are according to our own thinking, i believe that we all are strongly influenced by the society.
    How many of us will refrain from doing things because it is morally wrong in the eyes of the society.
    i strongly believe that the things that we do are sometimes strongly influenced by the society. we are afraid how the society would view us and how they would criticise us.
    how many times would our parents compare us with their friend's son/ daughter. this is because it is part of our culture to do so.
    Nevertheless, i am proud to be in this culture of mine.Though not perfect, but really special.

     
  • At November 5, 2009 at 9:28 PM , Anonymous Darrelle said...

    Culture shapes us and our response to other cultures. However, one's perception should not be influenced by his/her culture and have prejudices against other races/culture. This may be difficult as we are very conscious on how society will view us. Therefore, I feel that Singapore's culture is still the best as it teaches us to accept people from different cultures.

     
  • At November 5, 2009 at 9:41 PM , Anonymous Patricia said...

    I do not think that our Singaporean culture is successful in teaching us to accept people from other cultures.I believe that our people suffers from ethnocentrism,a belief that one's culture is superior than others.How often does one actually view someone from a different culture as their equal?We tend to assume that foreign workers from India are not as well educated as we are and we look down on them.For some, we might see foreigners who are holding high paid jobs as competitors for jobs.Never will we see them as someone who is there to help boost our economy.How does all these show the successfulness of our society in teaching us to accept people from other culturs?

     
  • At November 6, 2009 at 1:14 PM , Anonymous Jonathan said...

    Sad to say that there is ethnocentrism in most societies, be it a collectivist society or an individualistic one. Even though everyone is living at different places with different cultures, one thing for sure, all of us are still of the same kind - human beings. There's no such thing as you're superior or what. We should all respect each other's cultures and have this common belief that all cultures are actually the same.

     
  • At November 6, 2009 at 1:24 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

    Pros of being influenced by culture:
    It will seem like the people living in the same area (same culture) will be united as one whole community, making the people feel a stronger sense of belonging to their own cultures/countries.

    Cons of being influenced by culture:
    Sadly, people will feel restricted and being "controlled", unable to reveal their own true selfs.

     
  • At November 7, 2009 at 9:04 PM , Anonymous en said...

    Indeed in most societies there will be ethnocentrism. However it would be difficult to eliminate the belief that one's culture is superior to another. People might feel restricted by culture and it is exactly the cultural norms that they abide by in order to survive in the society. Many do not dare to do something that is unacceptable by their culture as they fear that the public will condemn their actions. Hence they would rather follow the crowd.

     
  • At November 7, 2009 at 9:54 PM , Anonymous Katy said...

    Ethnocentrism seems to be a coping mechanism that people use to deal with a world that they do not understand. Culture in itself is about following certain norms and traditions. And people resorting to thinking that they're set of beliefs is superior to any other seems to give them a sense of satisfaction. And even though no one would like to admit it, we are all at some level guilty of lording our beliefs over others.

     
  • At November 8, 2009 at 1:54 AM , Anonymous Xue Li said...

    I think culture has a very great impact on our lives. Imagine being the only odd one out of a large group of people. That will inevitably pose a pressure on the individual to eventually conform, no matter how gradually it may be, to the norms of the larger group. This is because culture can be used as a yardstick to determine what behaviour is acceptable and what is not in a group, and exposure to such behaviour over time can lead to one adopting it as well.

     
  • At November 8, 2009 at 7:30 PM , Anonymous HuangHuiQin said...

    Culture is a force that affects a society's basic values, perceptions, preference and behaviors. Values are being passed on from parents to children and are reinforced by schools, businesses, government etc. It is difficult to change these values as people need to maintain it from generations to generations.Thus, it is not an easy task to change one's belief and culture.

     
  • At November 8, 2009 at 9:07 PM , Anonymous Jolyn said...

    Indeed, culture is an invisible force that shapes the society in what it is today. Different societies have their own unique cultures which cannot be simply comprehended. We live in our own society where our thinking, perspectives and mindset are somehow being influenced by the culture. When we are looking at other societies, we are using our own thinking and mindset to understand them. As what is mentioned, riots, clashes and conflicts are stemmed from differences in cultures and thinking. Many conflicts are still ongoing despite years of fighting. One of the main reasons for such situations will definitely be cultural differences. We are bound by our own cultural norms, following what is acceptable or not, right or wrong. Therefore, when individuals found it unacceptable to accept a certain behaviour that deviates from the social norm, disagreements and protests will occur. So all in all, it is important to note that we have to respect each other cultures as this is what that have been passed down to all of us since young and it is hard to change these values. By mutual understanding and respect of cultures, there will be more peace in the world.

     
  • At November 8, 2009 at 9:36 PM , Anonymous en said...

    Living in a highly collectivist society, we tend to conform whenever we are under pressure from authoritative figures and I believe this is due to our culture. This is a value that our culture in Singapore portrays and is taught to us since we were young. It is not an easy feat to modify this belief that was instilled in us since young because most of us live by this value - never to question authority. It is also such that we are not given much opportunity to voice out our opinions regarding authority. This is because we associate questioning of authority with fear hence we dare not share our views openly.

     
  • At November 8, 2009 at 10:15 PM , Anonymous Liting said...

    Actually, I think that values and beliefs are more open to change or rather, flexible. It can include people's views like selective perceptions, contrast effects, stereotyping or projection. It can also be affected and altered due to our constantly changing society and environment.

     
  • At November 8, 2009 at 10:46 PM , Anonymous Li En said...

    Culture gives us an identity. Culture gives us a sense of belonging. Despite all the good things of cultures, i believe that we shouldnt allow culture to influence us to become a different person.

     
  • At November 8, 2009 at 10:51 PM , Anonymous Hui Min said...

    Yeah I agree with what Li En has mentioned earlier...this is somewhat similar to the a collectivist country... People usually conform to government policies... For example in China, there is a one-child policy... It is good in the sense that it helps to control the population boom of the country, but if we stop and think for a while, how many parents will be willing to abort their second children (that comes by accident)? By right, it is a harsh reality... and I believe this is why there are cultural riots happening in the world...

     
  • At November 8, 2009 at 11:04 PM , Anonymous Vina said...

    In the Singapore context, I do agree that people are governed by rules and regulations. When it comes to expression of views, it is known to the people that everyone has the right to freely express our thoughts. Different views we may have but not everyone speak them out openly. Why is that so?

    Perhaps it is the Asian culture that shapes our collectivist mindset, and it differs from individuals. Asians are known to be more conservative so to a certain extent acting or think differently may seem as a deviant act

     
  • At November 8, 2009 at 11:11 PM , Anonymous Rachel said...

    i think there are pros and cons to both individualism and collectivism. However, what matters most is how we learn to appreciate the benefits of these two sets of culture and understand each other's culture. In this case, I feel that American has very often interfered in the way another government runs its country just because it does not agree with the way the other country is being run. The most important thing is to understand and respect each other's culture in order to prevent conflicts.

     
  • At November 8, 2009 at 11:38 PM , Anonymous lydia said...

    It is indeed true that we are influenced by culture. I personally prefer to live in an individualistic country, because i do not like the feeling of being "controlled". But well, I believe that both a collectivist and individualistic country has its own pros and cons, and it depends on us, whether we want to get influenced by culture or not. (:

     

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home